02.12.2011, Результаты многокритериальной оптимизации

<accesscontrol>SuperUsers</accesscontrol> Результаты расчетов

Частотный диапазон L1

L1OC

Multi-objective optimization for L1OC signal

Signal	Antijamming w=8.00	Astronomy w=2.00	Accurancy w=9.00	MultiPath w=6.00	Inter from w=3.00	Inter to w=1.00	Search w=8.00	Complexity w=10.00	Intra w=7.00	Norm
BoCsin(0.250, 0.250) at 1565$f_b$	0.970	0.140	0.792	0.000	0.966	0.972	0.145	0.996	0.989	16.3969
BoCsin(0.500, 0.500) at 1565$f_b$	0.582	0.727	0.397	0.000	0.949	0.961	0.304	0.868	0.608	12.0368
BoCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1565$f_b$	0.195	1.000	0.198	0.000	0.902	0.927	0.638	1.000	0.226	12.0958
BoCcos(0.250, 0.250) at 1565$f_b$	0.886	0.485	0.614	0.000	0.947	0.959	0.145	0.998	0.833	15.0236
BPSK(0.500) at 1565$f_b$	1.000	0.000	1.000	0.000	0.987	0.988	0.145	0.465	1.000	15.0577
BPSK(0.500) at 1566$f_b$	1.000	0.117	1.000	0.000	1.000	1.000	0.145	0.908	1.000	16.9683
BPSK(0.500) at 1570$f_b$	1.000	0.842	1.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.145	0.997	1.000	17.2508
BPSK(0.750) at 1565$f_b$	0.774	0.091	0.642	0.000	0.976	0.980	0.228	0.804	0.759	13.3236
BPSK(1.000) at 1565$f_b$	0.613	0.201	0.481	0.000	0.968	0.974	0.304	0.465	0.603	9.8855
BPSK(1.000) at 1566$f_b$	0.613	0.360	0.481	0.000	0.975	0.979	0.304	0.908	0.603	12.6130
BPSK(1.250) at 1565$f_b$	0.489	0.350	0.386	0.000	0.960	0.969	0.389	0.931	0.484	12.0335
BPSK(1.500) at 1565$f_b$	0.387	0.431	0.321	0.000	0.952	0.963	0.478	0.731	0.383	10.1500
BPSK(2.000) at 1565$f_b$	0.226	0.463	0.241	0.000	0.936	0.951	0.638	0.731	0.226	9.9819
BPSK(2.500) at 1565$f_b$	0.102	0.599	0.192	0.000	0.919	0.938	0.815	0.997	0.101	12.4903
BPSK(3.000) at 1565$f_b$	0.000	0.844	0.160	0.000	0.905	0.927	1.000	0.997	0.000	13.2878

L1SC

Multi-objective optimization for L1SC signal

Signal	Antijamming w=8.00	Astronomy w=2.00	Accurancy w=6.00	MultiPath w=2.00	Inter from GPS w=2.00	Inter to GPS w=1.00	Search w=6.00	Complexity w=6.00	Intra w=10.00	Norm
BoCsin(3.250, 1.750) at 1563$f_b$	1.000	0.848	0.971	0.000	0.822	0.891	0.559	0.739	0.929	14.8836
BoCsin(6.125, 1.750) at 1565$f_b$	0.036	0.151	0.525	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.559	0.900	0.985	12.1448
BoCsin(3.250, 1.875) at 1563$f_b$	0.936	0.887	0.969	0.000	0.821	0.888	0.599	0.875	0.803	14.1925
BoCsin(3.750, 1.875) at 1568$f_b$	0.915	0.610	0.878	0.000	0.924	0.910	0.599	0.912	1.000	15.1643
BoCsin(5.125, 1.875) at 1564$f_b$	0.171	0.953	0.621	0.000	0.593	0.631	0.599	0.978	0.749	11.1638
BoCsin(5.625, 1.875) at 1565$f_b$	0.166	0.415	0.577	0.000	0.216	0.240	0.599	0.872	0.894	11.6155
BoCsin(3.250, 2.000) at 1563$f_b$	0.889	0.910	0.967	0.000	0.825	0.886	0.639	0.750	0.665	13.0509
BoCsin(4.000, 2.000) at 1567$f_b$	0.750	0.976	0.822	0.000	0.928	0.917	0.639	0.676	0.852	13.1236
BoCsin(4.000, 2.000) at 1568$f_b$	0.750	0.615	0.822	0.000	0.899	0.918	0.639	0.709	0.852	13.0900
BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1564$f_b$	0.352	0.976	0.650	0.000	0.756	0.804	0.639	0.748	0.770	11.1337
BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1565$f_b$	0.352	0.561	0.650	0.000	0.538	0.648	0.639	0.607	0.770	10.6384
BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1566$f_b$	0.352	0.406	0.650	0.000	0.427	0.518	0.639	0.716	0.770	10.8241
BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1567$f_b$	0.352	1.000	0.650	0.000	0.658	0.688	0.639	0.748	0.770	11.1096
BoCsin(6.000, 2.000) at 1565$f_b$	0.000	0.718	0.538	0.000	0.080	0.083	0.639	0.676	0.720	9.7743
BoCsin(4.250, 2.125) at 1567$f_b$	0.606	0.488	0.776	0.000	0.884	0.862	0.693	0.928	0.725	12.2867
BoCsin(4.500, 2.250) at 1566$f_b$	0.462	0.130	0.732	0.000	0.750	0.732	0.734	0.791	0.628	10.8225
BoCsin(4.500, 2.250) at 1567$f_b$	0.462	0.793	0.732	0.000	0.828	0.811	0.734	0.823	0.628	11.0488
BoCsin(5.625, 2.250) at 1565$f_b$	0.063	0.494	0.578	0.000	0.299	0.319	0.734	0.892	0.524	9.4440
BoCsin(5.625, 2.250) at 1566$f_b$	0.063	0.915	0.578	0.000	0.180	0.264	0.734	1.000	0.524	9.9340
BoCsin(4.750, 2.375) at 1565$f_b$	0.330	0.987	0.692	0.000	0.692	0.728	0.775	0.836	0.502	10.1274
BoCsin(4.750, 2.375) at 1566$f_b$	0.330	0.273	0.692	0.000	0.642	0.646	0.775	0.944	0.502	10.2730
BoCsin(3.125, 2.500) at 1563$f_b$	0.789	0.928	0.999	0.000	0.859	0.893	0.816	0.893	0.314	12.0623
BoCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1565$f_b$	0.201	0.074	0.659	0.000	0.600	0.690	0.816	0.666	0.402	8.7317
BoCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1566$f_b$	0.201	0.694	0.659	0.000	0.530	0.601	0.816	0.774	0.402	9.1287
BoCsin(5.250, 2.625) at 1565$f_b$	0.079	0.210	0.630	0.000	0.508	0.573	0.857	0.885	0.311	8.9746
BoCsin(5.250, 2.625) at 1566$f_b$	0.079	0.848	0.630	0.000	0.421	0.547	0.857	0.994	0.311	9.4985
BoCcos(3.250, 1.750) at 1563$f_b$	0.994	0.852	0.970	0.000	0.820	0.889	0.559	0.739	0.904	14.7015
BoCcos(3.250, 1.875) at 1563$f_b$	0.934	0.881	0.968	0.000	0.820	0.887	0.599	0.875	0.791	14.1146
BoCcos(5.125, 1.875) at 1564$f_b$	0.170	0.961	0.621	0.000	0.594	0.631	0.599	0.978	0.794	11.4774
BoCcos(3.000, 2.000) at 1564$f_b$	0.894	0.000	0.996	0.000	0.848	0.862	0.639	0.601	0.730	13.0923
BoCcos(3.250, 2.000) at 1563$f_b$	0.888	0.905	0.967	0.000	0.825	0.886	0.639	0.750	0.665	13.0402
BoCcos(3.375, 2.250) at 1563$f_b$	0.605	0.666	0.885	0.000	0.771	0.844	0.734	0.902	0.488	11.3579
BoCcos(3.125, 2.500) at 1563$f_b$	0.790	0.922	1.000	0.000	0.860	0.893	0.816	0.893	0.314	12.0682
BoCcos(2.750, 2.750) at 1565$f_b$	0.669	0.723	0.996	0.000	1.000	1.000	0.897	0.568	0.188	10.7525
BoCcos(2.875, 2.875) at 1564$f_b$	0.559	0.848	0.953	0.000	0.856	0.867	0.938	0.856	0.095	10.8720
BoCcos(3.000, 3.000) at 1564$f_b$	0.453	0.418	0.913	0.000	0.833	0.845	1.000	0.644	0.000	9.9154

Частотный диапазон L2

L2OC

Multi-objective optimization for L2OC signal (Top 30)

Signal	Antijamming w=8.00	Accurancy w=9.00	MultiPath w=6.00	Inter from w=3.00	Inter to w=1.00	Search w=8.00	Complexity w=10.00	Intra w=7.00	Norm
BoCcos(1.000, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.309	0.153	0.000	0.842	0.855	0.374	0.647	0.289	8.3693
BOCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.374	0.198	0.000	0.892	0.901	0.374	0.649	0.409	8.9126
BoCcos(0.500, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.610	0.308	0.000	0.916	0.923	0.179	0.564	0.576	9.4852
BoCcos(1.000, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.434	0.172	0.000	0.843	0.856	0.179	0.727	0.541	9.5327
BOCsin(1.000, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.487	0.184	0.000	0.868	0.879	0.179	0.727	0.578	9.8393
BoCcos(1.500, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.211	0.111	0.000	0.817	0.835	0.374	0.863	0.263	9.8657
BoCcos(2.000, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.133	0.086	0.000	0.791	0.809	0.374	0.889	0.252	9.9559
BoCcos(1.000, 1.000) at 1219$f_b$	0.309	0.153	0.000	0.928	0.936	0.374	0.836	0.289	9.9779
BoCcos(1.500, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.312	0.119	0.000	0.820	0.837	0.179	0.837	0.544	10.0343
BOCsin(1.500, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.269	0.125	0.000	0.842	0.856	0.374	0.863	0.324	10.0793
BOCsin(2.000, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.186	0.092	0.000	0.817	0.832	0.374	0.889	0.289	10.0847
BOCsin(1.500, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.356	0.120	0.000	0.835	0.849	0.179	0.836	0.553	10.1528
BoCcos(0.750, 0.750) at 1220$f_b$	0.435	0.209	0.000	0.874	0.885	0.281	0.814	0.420	10.1620
BoCcos(1.000, 1.000) at 1215$f_b$	0.309	0.153	0.000	0.822	0.837	0.374	0.890	0.289	10.3451
BOCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1219$f_b$	0.374	0.198	0.000	0.957	0.962	0.374	0.838	0.409	10.4267
BOCsin(0.500, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.675	0.397	0.000	0.940	0.945	0.179	0.569	0.701	10.4503
BoCcos(1.000, 0.750) at 1220$f_b$	0.379	0.173	0.000	0.852	0.865	0.281	0.890	0.372	10.4894
BoCcos(1.500, 1.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.133	0.102	0.000	0.814	0.833	0.587	0.890	0.119	10.5123
BOCsin(1.000, 0.750) at 1220$f_b$	0.390	0.174	0.000	0.860	0.872	0.281	0.889	0.379	10.5218
BoCcos(0.750, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.511	0.224	0.000	0.880	0.890	0.179	0.821	0.548	10.6163
BoCcos(2.000, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.218	0.091	0.000	0.795	0.812	0.179	0.931	0.552	10.6642
BoCcos(1.000, 1.000) at 1218$f_b$	0.309	0.153	0.000	0.948	0.954	0.374	0.917	0.289	10.6820
BOCsin(0.750, 0.750) at 1220$f_b$	0.499	0.263	0.000	0.919	0.926	0.281	0.810	0.531	10.6972
BOCsin(2.000, 0.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.255	0.090	0.000	0.807	0.823	0.179	0.930	0.550	10.7098
BOCsin(1.500, 1.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.198	0.132	0.000	0.856	0.869	0.587	0.890	0.240	10.7417
BoCcos(0.500, 0.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.610	0.308	0.000	0.963	0.967	0.179	0.753	0.576	10.7571
BOCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1215$f_b$	0.374	0.198	0.000	0.836	0.846	0.374	0.892	0.409	10.7651
BOCsin(1.250, 0.750) at 1220$f_b$	0.330	0.141	0.000	0.836	0.850	0.281	0.953	0.365	10.8621
BoCcos(1.250, 0.750) at 1220$f_b$	0.322	0.140	0.000	0.830	0.844	0.281	0.955	0.369	10.8692
BoCcos(1.250, 1.000) at 1220$f_b$	0.289	0.139	0.000	0.844	0.857	0.374	0.961	0.267	10.9020

L2SC

Multi-objective optimization for L2SC signal (Top 30)

Signal	Antijamming w=8.00	Accurancy w=6.00	MultiPath w=2.00	Inter from w=2.00	Inter to w=1.00	Search w=6.00	Complexity w=6.00	Intra w=10.00	Norm
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.000	0.437	0.000	0.340	0.386	1.000	0.676	0.006	7.7418
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.000	0.437	0.000	0.048	0.100	1.000	0.751	0.006	7.9501
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.188	0.495	0.000	0.532	0.571	1.000	0.640	0.002	7.9558
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.199	0.495	0.000	0.539	0.578	1.000	0.640	0.001	7.9745
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.218	0.465	0.000	0.557	0.576	1.000	0.676	0.027	8.0584
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1218$f_b$	0.000	0.437	0.000	0.017	0.000	1.000	0.783	0.006	8.0601
BoCcos(4.750, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.126	0.470	0.000	0.483	0.521	1.000	0.722	0.003	8.0609
BOCsin(4.750, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.135	0.470	0.000	0.487	0.526	1.000	0.722	0.002	8.0697
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.188	0.495	0.000	0.330	0.379	1.000	0.716	0.002	8.1292
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.199	0.495	0.000	0.343	0.393	1.000	0.715	0.001	8.1478
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1217$f_b$	0.000	0.437	0.000	0.269	0.169	1.000	0.816	0.006	8.1936
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1218$f_b$	0.188	0.495	0.000	0.184	0.218	1.000	0.748	0.002	8.2088
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1218$f_b$	0.199	0.495	0.000	0.200	0.233	1.000	0.747	0.001	8.2263
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.218	0.465	0.000	0.375	0.399	1.000	0.751	0.027	8.2430
BoCcos(4.750, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.126	0.470	0.000	0.257	0.302	1.000	0.798	0.003	8.2608
BOCsin(4.750, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.135	0.470	0.000	0.266	0.311	1.000	0.797	0.002	8.2695
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1221$f_b$	0.000	0.437	0.000	0.556	0.585	1.000	0.816	0.006	8.2702
BoCcos(4.250, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.251	0.522	0.000	0.573	0.624	1.000	0.686	0.002	8.2763
BoCcos(4.000, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.318	0.554	0.000	0.609	0.673	1.000	0.603	0.001	8.2781
BOCsin(4.250, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.262	0.525	0.000	0.582	0.635	1.000	0.686	0.001	8.3070
BOCsin(4.000, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.330	0.555	0.000	0.615	0.678	1.000	0.603	0.002	8.3120
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1218$f_b$	0.218	0.465	0.000	0.278	0.279	1.000	0.783	0.027	8.3301
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1217$f_b$	0.188	0.495	0.000	0.377	0.352	1.000	0.780	0.002	8.3466
BoCcos(4.750, 2.500) at 1218$f_b$	0.126	0.470	0.000	0.143	0.163	1.000	0.830	0.003	8.3594
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1217$f_b$	0.199	0.495	0.000	0.388	0.364	1.000	0.779	0.001	8.3644
BOCsin(4.750, 2.500) at 1218$f_b$	0.135	0.470	0.000	0.153	0.171	1.000	0.830	0.002	8.3675
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1221$f_b$	0.188	0.495	0.000	0.630	0.670	1.000	0.780	0.002	8.4267
BoCcos(3.750, 2.500) at 1220$f_b$	0.322	0.564	0.000	0.590	0.654	1.000	0.649	0.012	8.4302
BoCcos(4.000, 2.500) at 1219$f_b$	0.318	0.554	0.000	0.474	0.538	1.000	0.678	0.001	8.4407
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1221$f_b$	0.199	0.495	0.000	0.633	0.675	1.000	0.779	0.001	8.4430

Частотный диапазон L3

L3SC/OC

Multi-objective optimization for L3SC signal (Top 30)

Signal	Antijamming w=10.00	Accurancy w=5.00	MultiPath w=2.00	Inter from w=5.00	Inter to w=5.00	Search w=5.00	Complexity w=7.00	Intra w=10.00	Norm
BoCcos(4.000, 4.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.085	0.629	0.000	0.165	0.841	0.784	0.909	0.000	9.2071
BoCcos(4.500, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.232	0.628	0.000	0.200	0.716	0.686	0.974	0.132	9.4380
BOCsin(4.500, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.260	0.632	0.000	0.208	0.713	0.686	0.975	0.190	9.6149
BoCcos(3.750, 3.750) at 1175$f_b$	0.373	0.670	0.000	0.192	0.745	0.735	1.000	0.209	10.3336
BPSK(10.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.000	0.798	0.000	0.692	0.170	1.000	1.000	0.230	10.3869
BoCcos(4.000, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.522	0.701	0.000	0.294	0.633	0.686	0.920	0.187	10.4158
BOCsin(4.000, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.539	0.701	0.000	0.299	0.636	0.686	0.920	0.198	10.5310
BoCcos(5.000, 3.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.211	0.575	0.000	0.088	0.816	0.588	0.945	0.594	10.8294
BPSK(9.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.230	0.835	0.000	0.699	0.143	0.950	1.000	0.385	11.0380
BOCsin(5.000, 3.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.302	0.579	0.000	0.115	0.710	0.588	0.945	0.675	11.3290
BoCcos(3.750, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.675	0.742	0.000	0.351	0.577	0.686	0.983	0.187	11.5467
BOCsin(3.750, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.695	0.746	0.000	0.361	0.593	0.686	0.983	0.215	11.7477
BoCcos(3.500, 3.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.684	0.720	0.000	0.235	0.591	0.686	0.864	0.469	11.8378
BOCsin(4.000, 3.250) at 1175$f_b$	0.681	0.705	0.000	0.286	0.629	0.637	0.993	0.375	11.9685
BoCcos(4.000, 3.250) at 1175$f_b$	0.680	0.706	0.000	0.284	0.629	0.637	0.994	0.413	12.0907
BoCcos(4.500, 3.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.358	0.608	0.000	0.000	0.789	0.588	0.939	0.765	12.1689
BPSK(9.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.472	0.885	0.000	0.709	0.097	0.900	0.909	0.585	12.2344
BoCcos(3.500, 3.500) at 1174$f_b$	0.684	0.720	0.000	0.303	0.713	0.686	0.970	0.469	12.4321
BoCcos(3.750, 3.250) at 1175$f_b$	0.834	0.748	0.000	0.335	0.579	0.637	0.966	0.402	12.9097
BOCsin(3.750, 3.250) at 1175$f_b$	0.842	0.749	0.000	0.337	0.579	0.637	0.967	0.442	13.0983
BoCcos(4.000, 3.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.807	0.709	0.000	0.243	0.792	0.588	0.840	0.654	13.4482
BoCcos(4.000, 3.000) at 1174$f_b$	0.807	0.709	0.000	0.311	0.849	0.588	0.946	0.654	13.9082
BOCsin(4.000, 3.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.908	0.713	0.000	0.285	0.388	0.588	0.840	0.720	14.0011
BoCcos(3.500, 3.250) at 1175$f_b$	0.994	0.796	0.000	0.396	0.537	0.637	0.938	0.435	14.0692
BoCcos(4.000, 3.000) at 1173$f_b$	0.807	0.709	0.000	0.539	0.892	0.588	0.992	0.654	14.2988
BPSK(8.500) at 1175$f_b$	0.728	0.936	0.000	0.721	0.053	0.850	0.909	0.776	14.3770
BOCsin(4.000, 3.000) at 1174$f_b$	0.908	0.713	0.000	0.343	0.471	0.588	0.946	0.720	14.4222
BOCsin(4.000, 3.000) at 1173$f_b$	0.908	0.713	0.000	0.551	0.560	0.588	0.991	0.720	14.8076
BOCsin(4.000, 4.000) at 1175$f_b$	0.746	0.811	0.000	0.530	0.296	0.784	0.908	0.941	15.0173
BoCcos(4.000, 3.000) at 1170$f_b$	0.807	0.709	0.000	1.000	1.000	0.588	0.976	0.654	15.0285

Примечания

— Корогодин Илья • 04:13, 3 декабря 2011 • нет комментариев

[ Хронологический вид ]Комментарии

(нет элементов)

Войдите, чтобы комментировать.